Usually, yes. If your garage door has two springs of the same age and one breaks, replacing both is generally recommended. They have usually worked through the same opening and closing cycles, so the remaining spring may also be near the end of its useful life.
Why replace a spring that has not broken?
An unbroken spring is not necessarily a healthy spring. Keeping an older spring can mean another breakdown and a second repair visit. Replacing the pair lets the technician set up and check the complete spring system together.
This does not mean the two springs must always look identical. Some door systems use different spring sizes by design. The important point is that the selected springs work together to balance your particular door.
Is replacing only one ever reasonable?
Tell the technician if the other spring was replaced recently, and provide the repair record if you have it. Ask whether the door manufacturer’s instructions allow it to remain and how its condition and specifications were checked. A recent replacement is a reason to ask questions, not proof that keeping it is appropriate.
Some doors use only one spring. A recommendation to replace a pair should begin with confirming the system you actually have.
What should you ask before approving the repair?
Ask which springs the quote includes, how they match the door, and whether final balance and operating checks are included. If higher-cycle springs are proposed, ask what the rating means for your use rather than assuming a guaranteed lifespan.
Do not keep operating a door with a broken spring or attempt to adjust springs, cables, or bottom brackets. These parts can release dangerous force.
Contact Rockstar Garage Door Services for garage door spring replacement in San Diego and a clear explanation of your repair options.